5 Best Mattress Stores in New York City

ByFrancisco Lopez

Mattress shopping online sounds convenient until you’re stuck with a bed that felt fine in a photo but wrong the moment you actually lie down on it. Finding the best mattress stores in New York City means you don’t have to gamble on a purchase this important sight unseen. NYC has plenty of real, walk-in showrooms—here’s where locals actually go to test before they buy.

1. The Sleep Loft (Chelsea)

Best Mattress Stores in New York City

The Sleep Loft has built its name as an online mattress showroom based right in the city, carrying a wide range of top-rated online mattress brands including Helix, Leesa, Brooklyn Bedding, DreamCloud, Nectar, Birch, Puffy, and Bear all under one roof. The idea is simple: most of these brands only sell online, so The Sleep Loft gives you a place to actually lie down on them before committing.

Phone: +1 646-400-5758

Hours: Monday – Friday 11:00 AM – 8:00 PM, Saturday 11:00 AM – 7:00 PM, Sunday 11:00 AM – 6:00 PM

Address: 231 West 18th Street, New York, NY 10011

Also worth knowing: The Sleep Loft has grown to ten showrooms across New York City, Brooklyn, and New Jersey, including additional Manhattan locations in Midtown and the Upper East Side, so there’s likely one closer to you than Chelsea if that’s not convenient.

2. Casper Sleep Shop (Williamsburg, Brooklyn)

Casper needs little introduction as one of the original direct-to-consumer mattress brands, and its Williamsburg Sleep Shop lets you try the mattress, pillows, and bedding in person rather than ordering blind. Sleep Specialists on staff can walk you through the lineup and help you compare firmness levels side by side.

Phone Number: +1 347-391-3970

Hours: Monday – Thursday 10:00 AM – 7:00 PM, Friday – Saturday 10:00 AM – 8:00 PM, Sunday 11:00 AM – 7:00 PM

Address: 66 N 3rd St, Brooklyn, NY 11249

Also worth knowing: Casper operates several additional New York locations, including a spot on Lexington Avenue in Midtown, if Williamsburg isn’t the easiest stop for you.

3. SleePare (Chelsea)

SleePare takes a comparison-shopping approach, letting you feel and compare mattress offerings from multiple online retailers side by side in one visit instead of hopping between brand-specific stores. Customer reviews consistently mention a low-pressure, well-informed staff that walks you through the options rather than pushing a single brand.

Phone: +1 347-307-7096

Hours: Monday – Wednesday 10:00 AM – 8:00 PM, Thursday 10:00 AM – 7:00 PM, Friday – Sunday 10:00 AM – 8:00 PM

Address: 218 West 30th St, New York, NY 10001

Also worth knowing: The showroom sits within walking distance of Penn Station, Madison Square Garden, and Hudson Yards, which makes it an easy add-on if you’re already in the area.

4. Craig’s Beds (Manhattan)

Craig’s Beds has been family-owned and serving New Yorkers for more than 14 years, and it’s consistently rated among the top mattress stores in the city on both Yelp and Google. Unlike the online-first showrooms, Craig’s Beds carries established names like Beautyrest, Serta iComfort, and Summerfield, all manufactured in the United States.

Phone: +1 212-840-1717

Hours: Monday – Friday 10:30 AM – 6:30 PM, Saturday – Sunday 1:15 PM – 5:30 PM

Address: 246 W 38th St, Suite 205, New York, NY 10018

Also worth knowing: Craig’s Beds limits the number of shoppers in-store at any given time to keep the experience relaxed rather than rushed, and offers a 90-day comfort guarantee along with free delivery and setup.

5. Mattress Firm (Hell’s Kitchen)

For a more traditional big-box mattress shopping experience, Mattress Firm’s Hell’s Kitchen location puts a wide selection of established mattress brands within easy reach of Midtown, just west of Times Square. It’s a solid option if you’d rather compare a broad range of conventional brands in one visit rather than focus on newer online-first names.

Phone: +1 646-581-9257

Hours: Monday – Saturday 10:00 AM – 8:00 PM, Sunday 10:00 AM – 7:00 PM

Address: 590 9th Ave, New York, NY 10036

Also worth knowing: The location sits in a neighborhood known for its dense concentration of restaurants and foot traffic, so it’s an easy stop if you’re already running errands in the area.

What to Ask Before You Buy

A few questions are worth bringing to any of these showrooms, regardless of which one you visit:

  • What’s the sleep trial period? Most reputable stores offer at least a 30 to 90-night trial, since firmness that feels right for 15 minutes in a store doesn’t always hold up after a full night’s sleep.
  • Is delivery and setup included? In a city full of walk-up apartments, white-glove delivery that actually gets the mattress up the stairs matters more than it might elsewhere.
  • What’s the return or exchange policy if the firmness isn’t right? A no-hassle exchange process saves you from being stuck with a bed that didn’t work out.

Finding the Right Fit

Mattress shopping is one of those purchases where a showroom visit genuinely pays off, as firmness preference is too personal to judge online. Trying top options like Casper, Helix, or Craig’s Beds in person ensures you get the right fit. For more home decor inspiration, you can also explore our guide to the best furniture stores in New York City on our site to find top spots for every room.

Similar Posts